In 1971, US President Richard Nixon "untied" one of the leading currencies of the planet – the US dollar – from gold. Money in the modern world has ceased to be provided with a ringing metal, and gold (like silver or platinum) has become an independent commodity on the stock exchange. At the same time, gold has long been recognized as a "hard" currency that retains its solvency in times of crisis, and central banks of different countries keep gold and foreign exchange reserves in their vaults, constantly replenishing them. The planet's gold reserves are exhausted, and, according to various experts, they will run out by 2030-2040. Meanwhile, along with the widespread use of gold in the banking sector, the obvious consumption of it by the jewelry industry (it is especially in demand in such a role in India, which is a well – known importer of this metal), gold is irreplaceable in those devices that have become an integral part of our life-in electronics. Therefore, its value in the long term is unconditional.
But is gold interesting as an investment asset on the horizon of 3-5-7 years? What are the risks of such investments? What are the ways to invest in gold? We will answer these questions in the sections of the article:
Features of investing in Gold
Gold and other precious metals have always been protective assets for investors in times of crisis. And the new crisis caused by the COVID-19 epidemic was accompanied at the peak of the pandemic by a rapid increase in prices for the "yellow" metal. Governments and major banks of the world consider gold a protective and stabilizing asset, increasing the share of gold reserves in anticipation or during crises. The gold reserves stored in the world's central banks amount to more than 33 thousand tons at the time of writing, which corresponds to 20% of all gold ever extracted from the bowels of the planet. A significant share of gold reserves has been replenished over the past 10-15 years. In 2019, the world's Central banks added more than 600 tons of gold to their vaults, which formed the maximum volume of purchases for the period since 2010. The World Gold Council review for 2020 reported that central banks and financial institutions have been key buyers of gold throughout since 2010.
Taking into account the protective function of this precious metal recognized by major market participants, investors, analyzing gold prices, in the simplest approximation, associate price changes with global macroeconomic changes. During periods of relative global calm, the price of gold is stable. But in the conditions of a tense economic situation caused by a variety of factors, the price of a "stabilization tool" is growing.
If we consider the correlation of gold prices with individual components of the crisis, it turns out that there is not always a direct dependence of price changes on the deterioration of macroeconomic indicators. In particular, there is no pronounced correspondence between the chart of the consumer price index, which characterizes the inflation of the US dollar, and the chart of gold prices, since gold is not a commodity, only a small share of it participates in production cycles. Consequently, its price reacts to the purchasing power of money differently than the prices of other goods. The graph below shows the dynamics of gold prices over the past 10 years and the US consumer price index. As we can see, some of the ups and downs of one of them coincide with the symmetrical drawdowns and rises of the second, but, in general, there is no global correlation.
Read more: Causes of inflation and scientific approaches to their study
One of the significant factors that also affects the price of gold is the presence of permanent large buyers in the form of reserve banks. In the case of any large purchases on the market, the price of gold increases. As an example, we can consider the periods of purchases of China and India in the last two decades for the creation and expansion of federal reserves, at the time of which there were rises in the price of gold; if the moments of purchase of two or three large buyers coincide, the price dynamics is even brighter. This factor, in addition to its influence, also has absolute unpredictability; it is almost impossible to predict what the future volumes of purchases of the largest market players will be and when they will take place.
These factors make the gold metal, on the one hand, a good protective asset of the investor's portfolio, and, on the other hand, it is hardly predictable on the short-term horizon.
Pros and cons of investing in gold
Advantages of such investments:
- High liquidity. Even in times of global economic or political turmoil, gold can be sold, albeit with some losses. Both banks and buyers, pawnshops, private individuals buy valuable metals or exchange them for useful goods, even in the most difficult times.
- The limit of cost reduction. Unlike currencies and various securities, gold can fall in value (or grow), but it will never completely devalue.
- The stability of the price increase in the long term. The price of the precious metal is rising slowly, but steadily. Here, as in the case of the market, we can say that "gold (in the long term) is always growing."
Disadvantages:
- The duration of investment growth. A noticeable economic effect from investing in gold is observed on the investment horizon of at least 10-15 years.
- Relatively low profitability. This disadvantage follows from the previous one - investing in a precious metal is not the most profitable tool of the portfolio.
- The presence of a spread for physical gold. The purchase of physical gold from banks and specialized companies does not occur at the market price; there is always a spread discount to buy or a margin on sale. If an investor decided to buy an ingot or coin and sell it on the same day, the difference between buying and selling for him would be a significant difference. This is some kind of analog of buying/selling currency at an exchange office. Therefore, with small amounts of investment, in order to generate income, you will have to wait for a serious increase in the cost of the metal, which will block the spread.
- Quite high volatility of the metal price for short periods of time, combined with the complexity of predicting the behavior of the asset. Gold allows you to both get a good income in a short period of time, and lose significant amounts at a similar distance.
- Unlike bonds, dividend shares or bank deposits, in this case, the buyer does not have the opportunity to receive regular interest deductions from the invested money; income is possible only when selling metal due to the difference in purchase and sale prices.
Read more: Volatility: types, how to track and how to use
Ways to invest in Gold
Bullion and gold coins
The purchase of physical metal in bullion and gold coins (collectible or investment) is carried out in banks or specialized organizations. Both of them earn on the "exchange rate difference" of selling and buying (spread), so they will have to buy at a price higher than the current market price, and sell at a price lower. Both the cost of the metal itself and the size of the spread in different banks are different. It is advisable for an investor to consider different options to choose the most profitable one.
Since the metal in coins and bullion does not give regular (for example, dividend) income, the only thing that generates profit here is the difference in the purchase and sale prices.
When buying bullion and coins, you must pay VAT. However, when selling gold, it is possible to issue a tax deduction. If the total amount of the purchase/sale does not exceed the specified amount, then the tax losses will be zero; but if the amounts are higher, the investor also loses on VAT payment. Thus, in order to make a profit, the investor needs to wait for the price of gold to increase by an amount that covers both the spread and the tax paid. This period, as practice shows, can be quite long.
Physical gold requires certain storage conditions: in addition to protection from possible loss, you need to take care of the safety of the metal product, since any scratches or dents on this soft metal will lead to a discount when selling. You can store gold in a bank, but renting a safe deposit box requires additional costs.
However, such gold is a protective asset in case of the most terrible shocks. It is relatively easy to transport, especially in coins, it is available and liquid outside the Internet and specialized programs, in any circumstances it has its own price, guaranteed to be different from zero.
Depersonalized metal account
This is a specialized account that stores not money (as in a bank deposit) and not securities (as in a brokerage account), but a certain number of grams of metal, in our case – gold. The metal is credited to the account virtually.
Such an acquisition of gold does not require payment of VAT and specific storage requirements, but it is possible to sell it, unlike physical gold, back only to the same bank in which it was purchased. And here, too, there is a spread set by the bank. To make a profit, the investor needs to wait for a noticeable price increase.
The dependence of the MMI on a particular bank makes this method of investment quite vulnerable. In case of revocation of the license and termination of the bank's activities, bankruptcy, depersonalized metal accounts do not fall under the protection of insurance companies, like deposits.
ETF for Gold
Gold ETF funds allow you to actually invest in gold without having to purchase it physically. The shares of such a fund will repeat the movements of the market price for the metal itself. Their purchase does not require VAT payment and does not have a spread.
Since the gold market is not at all young, there are quite a lot of gold funds on the market. The fund's shares can be purchased in rubles or in foreign currency. It is possible to see all of them and compare them with each other using the professional service for investors. In the "Choosing an ETF" section, you must specify the "Gold" strategy in the settings; the remaining criteria will be set automatically.
ETF Sprott Gold Miners
Since there is only one fund on the Russian stock exchanges containing shares of gold miners, and it was created only a few months ago, to understand the dynamics of such funds, consider the Sprott Gold Miners ETF (SGDM). This fund offers a portfolio of 25 shares of companies from the gold and silver mining industry, traded on US exchanges. The Foundation was established in 2014. and has net assets of $131.99 million. The main component of the portfolio is formed by Goldcorp, Inc., Kirkland Lake Gold and Newmont Mining Corp., each of which accounts for more than 14%. The fund's dividend yield is 0.76%. Since the value of gold miners ' shares depends on many factors, except for the metal price itself, there is no direct correlation between the fund and gold price charts, although the general trend coincides.
Read more: How to determine the trend: features and rules
Funds that invest entirely in metal have a feature that distinguishes them favorably from ETFs that invest in certain strategies; for example, in cybersecurity or electric vehicles: they are one - or two-component, that is, they consist entirely of one or two assets. An investor does not have to buy shares of a pool of companies, both promising and unprofitable, without the possibility of choice, and bear all the risks associated with this. Buying such a fund is almost similar to buying physical gold without the associated difficulties. However, ETFs for gold mining companies, being quite conservative, still collect a pool of shares of different companies, and thus carry the standard risk inherent in any other ETF: they include shares of both successful and low-promising, unprofitable or overvalued companies.
With a balanced professional approach, investing in these ETFs can show a good result. To implement this approach, an investor needs special knowledge of the theory of portfolio investment and support for special services for choosing ETFs, which allow assessing the risks and potential profitability of each instrument, determining the best entry point, forming a portfolio and evaluating its stability and efficiency.
This is another way to invest in gold without the difficulties, restrictions and additional expenses associated with the purchase of physical bars and coins or the opening of an MMI.
Read more: Bulls and bears, as well as other animals on the stock exchange
Newmont Corporation
This company is one of the world leaders in gold mining. Newmont is the only gold producer included in the S&P 500 index. The company has a century-old history of activity, and has been trading on the stock exchange since 1925.
Royal Gold, Inc
In relation to gold, this company uses an unusual business model. The company is not the owner of the mines and does not manage them. It buys precious metal flows from mining companies such as Goldcorp Inc. at a low fixed price in exchange for financing them in advance. This makes the business model more profitable than that of gold miners, since the company does not have to bear the risks associated with mining, and can provide precious metals at low prices. In addition to gold, the company is also a supplier of silver and copper. Royal Gold has a 16-year history of paying and increasing the size of dividends. The company's multipliers, in general, are close to the market average, but a PEG of 0.4 indicates a good growth potential.
Shares of gold mining companies are the best option for indirect investment in gold. First, stock prices do not have a direct correlation with the value of gold, which is dependent on the cycle in the economy. The value of shares is determined by a large number of factors ("What affects the value of shares"). In particular, it depends on the financial result of the company's activities. It depends not only on gold prices, but also on operational indicators and the effectiveness of the business model. And often during periods of rising gold prices, the shares of gold miners can show outstripping dynamics. Secondly, shares can bring additional income in the form of dividends.
But in order to get a higher income than alternative options for investing in gold, it is important to choose the right issuing companies for investment.
Conclusion
The general indicators of the stock market are alarming for some investors. Many people started talking about the possibility of a new bubble collapsing. In anticipation of whether the market will cope with the critical situation by correcting the indicators, or there will still be a significant correction, investors are looking for ways to protect their investments. In such a situation, the first thing that comes to mind for many is to shift their money into more conservative, but time-tested assets.
Since we have all been living in the digital space for a long time, investing in gold in the form of a metal seems to be an outdated and too expensive process. In addition, the very perception of gold by market players as an asset that works conditionally in opposition to other instruments makes it possible to reduce the risks of crises, but not to get stable capital gains, since in the periods between crises, investors tend to shift fixed assets from protective assets to growth assets. The price of gold during such periods of market growth (which usually last longer than periods of crisis) stagnates or decreases. ETFs for gold and shares of gold mining companies are time-tested assets, their price is more or less correlated with the price of the metal itself.
However, the best option is to distribute funds between different types of assets from different industries. This option will allow both to minimize risks, ensuring the safety of capital, and will allow its multiplication. Such papers should be selected carefully and precisely.